In this guide we’ll look at the best ice fishing boots.
We’ve compared durability, insulation, waterproofing and cost
to give you our top recommendations.

What Are The Best Ice Fishing Boots?

IMAGE RECOMMENDED PRODUCTSPRODUCT FEATURES
  • Rugged and durable
  • Very warm
  • Excellent waterproofing
  • Removable insulation
  • Comfortable, lightweight, and adjustable
  • Durable
  • Great traction
  • Rated to -60oF
  • Great waterproofing
  • Removable felt insulation
  • Rated to -60oF
  • Comfortable
  • Removable felt liner
  • Adjustable
  • More affordable

More Detailed Ice Fishing Boot Reviews

Muck Boot Arctic Sport Rubber High-Performance Winter Boot

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Rugged and durable
  • Very warm
  • Excellent waterproofing
OUR RATING
PRICE
VIEW LATEST PRICE →

Muck Boot Arctic Sport Rubber High-Performance Winter Boot Review

These pull-on boots are the real deal: tough, waterproof, and warm. In my opinion, they’re the best rubber ice fishing boots out there.

I’ve been wearing various Muck boots since I was a teenager for all sorts of outdoors and cold weather activities, from ice fishing to hunting to yardwork. These Muck winter boots are my time-tested favorites for ice fishing for a few reasons.

First off, they’re comfortable and warm; I can wear them for hours out on the ice and my feet don’t complain. The fleece lining is soft and insulating, and there’s also 2mm of thermal foam under the footbed to protect your feet from the cold ice. The 5mm neoprene is comfortable, flexible, and waterproof; it also retains your body heat quite well.

Second, the waterproofing is excellent. These boots have a rubber sole (providing solid traction) and rubber shell that encases the foot and extends above the ankle to provide even more waterproofing. The shaft measures approximately 14.5” from the arch, which is quite tall, allowing you to walk through some pretty heavy snow without getting any in your boots.

These Muck boots are rated for use from -40oF to 40oF. I’ve found that to be a good range for ice fishing and basically every cold weather outdoors activity I do: They’re nice and warm but don’t make my feet melt with sweat in “warmer” 30-40oF temperatures.

Baffin Men’s Wolf Snow Boot

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Removable insulation
  • Comfortable, lightweight, and adjustable
  • Durable
OUR RATING
PRICE
VIEW LATEST PRICE →

Baffin Men’s Wolf Snow Boot Review

These Baffin boots also have some great features to recommend them. I also find them very comfortable: The lightweight materials make these boots comfortable and easy to walk in, even over longer distances. Plus, they’ve got dual buckle straps and a drawstring collar that can be adjusted for fit and for taking them off easily.

The drawstring collar lets you pull the tops of the boots in taut, which is important if you’re in blustery conditions where snow might blow into your boots. With the collar, you can keep snow and slush out, and your feet will stay warm and dry. These boots are a little bit shorter, measuring 11” from the arch to the top.

Another nice feature is the removable insulation—this lets you pull the inner liner out to dry when needed. With the insulation inside, these boots are rated to -40oF. All in all, the Baffin boots offer good traction, durability, comfort, and warmth. They’re a good choice for ice fishing, snowmobiling, or just hiking around in the snow, and a strong contender for the best boots for ice fishing.

Muck Boots Extreme Conditions Winter Hunting Boot

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Great traction
  • Rated to -60oF
  • Great waterproofing
OUR RATING
PRICE
VIEW LATEST PRICE →

Muck Boots Extreme Conditions Winter Hunting Boot Review

Another great pair of pull-on Muck Boots, these are meant for extremely cold temperatures: They’re rated for comfort from -60oF to 30oF. They’ve got fleece lining and 2mm of thermal foam under the footbed. Plus, there’s an 8mm layer of neoprene, supplying comfort, warmth, and waterproofing.

Thanks to the Vibram Arctic Grip outsoles, these boots also have superb traction even on the slipperiest and most unstable of surfaces.

These boots have a 14” shaft and 1” platform. Overall, they’re ideal for cold-weather hunting, ice fishing, snow blowing, or snowmobiling, though they might be a bit too warm in milder temperatures (30-40oF).

Sorel Men’s Bear Extreme Snow Boot

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Removable felt insulation
  • Rated to -60oF
  • Comfortable
OUR RATING
PRICE
VIEW LATEST PRICE →

Sorel Men’s Bear Extreme Snow Boot Review

Measuring 13.5” from the arch to top, these Sorel Snow boots have a waterproof polyurethane-coated upper and a rubber shell that encases the foot for extra waterproofing. They’ve got laces at the ankle and a drawstring at the top, allowing you to adjust for comfort and to keep blowing snow out.

Inside, there’s removable insulation made of recycled felt. This liner can be a little tricky and come out when you take the boot off or get bunched down when you put the boot on. My solution is to put jut the liner on my foot and then slip it into the outer boot shell.

Rated down to -60oF, these boots are another extremely warm and comfortable option for ice fishing.

Kamik Men’s Greenbay 4 Cold-Weather Boot

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Removable felt liner
  • Adjustable
  • More affordable
OUR RATING
PRICE
VIEW LATEST PRICE →

Kamik Men’s Greenbay 4 Cold-Weather Boot Review

This Kamik Cold-weather boot is made of 600-denier nylon with a rubber sole and a shaft measuring 13”. They have removable insulated felt liners; again this is a convenient way to dry out your boots in the unlucky event that they become wet. The drawstring around the top, however, lets you pull the boots taut to prevent water or snow from entering.

Velcro closure straps are adjustable for fit and comfort. Rated to -40oF, these boots perform well in the snow and cold, but are less waterproof than other entries on this list. I would not wear these hiking or snowshoeing over long distances, but they work well for ice fishing.

Conclusion

There’s nothing better than an afternoon out on the ice, pulling in fish and sipping on hot chocolate…until you suddenly realize you can’t feel your toes. Avoid cold feet and spend all day outside in comfort by investing in some quality ice fishing boots.

So what are the best winter boots for ice fishing? Everyone has individual preferences and priorities, but I believe the five boots on this list are fantastic options, combining warmth, waterproofing, comfort, traction, and value.